Can Landlords Limit Certain Dog Breeds Because of Insurance?

Dated: 11/22/2018

Views: 69

Info taken from

I manage a property with a no-pets policy and am in the process of leasing it. The landlord decided to lease to a hearing-impaired tenant who is requesting her dog, a pit bull, be allowed as her assistance animal. The owner of the property has a homeowners insurance policy that prohibits "vicious" breeds, including pit bulls. What can the landlord do?

Generally speaking, the landlord must grant a reasonable accommodation, unless an exception applies. An accommodation is unreasonable if it imposes an undue financial or administrative burden on a housing provider’s operations. According to a 2006 memo from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, if a housing provider’s insurance carrier would cancel the insurance policy, substantially increase the costs of the insurance policy, or adversely change the policy terms because of the presence of a certain breed of dog or a certain animal, HUD will find that this imposes an undue financial and administrative burden.

Therefore, it is possible that the landlord may be able to deny this request for the assistance animal if there is the existence of such a restriction in the owner’s insurance policy. This situation may be perceived as an undue financial or administrative burden if the insurance carrier would cancel, substantially increase the costs, or adversely change the terms of the insurance policy if the landlord allowed the pit bull to reside with the tenant. However, because the HUD investigator will research this if a complaint is filed, the landlord may want to ascertain whether comparable insurance is available without the restriction before denying the request.

Have other real estate-related questions?  

Michelle Foreman

Fourth Generation Realtor, Texas Urban Living

C: 214-394-2487

Blog author image

Michelle Foreman

Michelle Foreman isn't one to focus solely on getting the job done but instead on getting the job done RIGHT. Michelle, a Fourth Generation Realtor, is certified as both a Senior Real Estate Speciali....

Latest Blog Posts

2019 Housing Forecast

Hearing news all over the board about what the housing market might do in 2019?  Read below!  Have additional questions on anything else real estate-related?  Contact me!Michelle

Read More

Fastest Growing Retirement Locations

Trying to decide where to retire?  The below info may help.  In the DFW area and need to sell your property before you move?  Call me!Michelle ForemanFourth Generation Realtor, Texas

Read More

50 items to get rid of

Cleaning out items is hard.  Moving and trying to figure out what to purge might be harder.  Below are 50 items you probably don't need.  Have additional real estate questions or

Read More

What types of homes did Texans purchase in 2018?

All types of properties were sold last year, but what were Texans purchasing?  Have other real estate-related questions or have a question about your home?Michelle ForemanFourth Generation

Read More